GeForce RTX 3070 Max-P is 30% faster than Max-Q in MSI gaming laptops

Published: 25th Jan 2021, 20:38 GMT   Comments

MSI laptops with NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3070 GPU tested

Two reviews featuring MSI’s latest gaming laptops equipped with GeForce RTX 3070 have been posted by the GenTechPC YouTube channel and then quickly taken private. However, we managed to write this article before that happened. 

GenTechPC is a retailer from whom you may purchase MSI GS66 Stealth and GE66 Raider laptops with either RTX 3070 or RTX 3080 graphics cards. On its YouTube channel, the retailer published the world’s first reviews of those laptops.

Both machines are equipped with the same Intel 10th Gen Core CPU, the i7-10870H (some of you might remember this CPU from this story), and NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3070 Laptop GPU based on Ampere architecture. Both series are targeted at different users, those who demand simply the best gaming experience and those who would rather sacrifice the performance for a lighter and thinner design. As a result, those laptops have different GPU variants. The GE66 Raider comes with the RTX 3070 Max-P while GS66 Stealth is equipped with RTX 3070 Max-Q.

MSI GE66 Raider & GS66 Stealth, Source: GenTechPC

The GE66 Raider features an RTX 3070 Laptop GPU known as Max-P with a boost clock of 1620 MHz and TGP of 115W. On the other hand, the GS66 Stealth features a Max-Q variant with a clock speed reduced to 1290 MHz and TGP reduced to 80W.  Do note, this does not take into account the Dynamic Boost technology which further increases TGP by 15 to 20W, depending on how much it can ‘borrow’ from CPU’s power.

NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3070 Laptop GPU, Source: GenTechPC

The GeForce RTX 3070 Max-P scores 27940 points in 3DMark Fire Strike (Graphics), while the Max-Q model only scores 21337 points. This means that the 115W model is 31% faster than the power-limited version:

NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3070 Laptop GPU, Source: GenTechPC

The internals of both laptops:

MSI GE66 Raider vs MSI GS66 Stealth , Source: GenTechPC

In a public statement, NVIDIA officially encouraged OEMs to list TGPs and clock speeds for their RTX 30 Laptop GPUs. MSI does not clarify those values, providing very misleading information to customers who will end up with 30% slower GPU simply by choosing GS66 Stealth laptop, rather than GE66:

MSI GE66 Raider vs MSI GS66 Stealth, Source: MSI

A good example of how RTX 30 TGP should be listed comes from Schenker XMG. The brand lists TGP targets including dynamic boost values but does not list clock speeds. One would ask, why do laptop makers list CPU clock speeds but do not list them for GPUs.

XMG PRO 15 (Early 2021) Specifications, Source: XMG

NVIDIA GeForce 30 Mobile
VideoCardz.comGeForce RTX 3080GeForce RTX 3070GeForce RTX 3060
CodenameGN20-E7GN20-E5GN20-E3
GPUGA104-775GA104-770GA106
CUDA Cores614451203840
GPU Clock1245 – 1710 MHz1290 – 1620 MHz1283 – 1703 MHz
Memory Bus256-bit256-bit192-bit
Memory8GB / 16GB GDDR68GB GDDR66GB GDDR6
TGPMax-P: 115W + 35W* + 15W**
Max-Q: 80W+ 65W* + 20W**
Max-P: 115W + 10W* + 15W**
Max-Q: 80W+ 40W* + 20W**
Max-P: 80W + 35W* + 15W**
Max-Q: 60W+ 50W* + 20W**
* Configurable TGP, ** Dynamic Boost technology

Source: GenTechPC (videos were taken private)




Comment Policy
  • Comments must be written in English.
  • Comments deemed to be spam or solely promotional in nature will be deleted. Including a link to relevant content is permitted, but comments should be relevant to the post topic.
  • Comments containing language or concepts that could be deemed offensive will be deleted. Note this may include abusive, threatening, pornographic, offensive, misleading or libelous language.
  • A failure to comply with these rules will result in a warning and, in extreme cases, a ban.
  • Please note that comments that attack or harass an individual directly will be deleted and such comments will result in a ban.
  • VideoCardz Moderating Team reserves the right to edit or delete any comments submitted to the site without notice.
  • If you have any questions about the commenting policy, please let us know through the Contact Page.
Hide Comment Policy
Comments